Best Gelato Shop near Penn Plaza, New York
World-Famous Gelato Steps from Penn Station and Madison Square Garden
Located in the heart of Midtown Manhattan, Anita Gelato Penn Plaza is the perfect destination for handcrafted frozen desserts before a game, after a concert, or during a day exploring New York City. Conveniently situated near Penn Station and Madison Square Garden, our location brings the world-famous Anita Gelato experience to one of the busiest and most exciting neighborhoods in Manhattan.
Whether you’re commuting through the city, attending an event, or searching for the best gelato shop in Penn Plaza, you’ll find an unforgettable selection of handcrafted flavors inspired by Mama Anita’s original recipes.
Discover More Than 150 Rotating Flavors
At Anita Gelato New York, every visit offers something new to explore. Guests can choose from a rotating collection of more than 150 flavors, including classic favorites, creative specialty recipes, fruit-forward sorbets, frozen yogurt selections, and options with no added sugar.
Popular offerings include:
- Premium artisan gelato made in-house
- Refreshing sorbets
- Frozen yogurt creations
- Sugar-free selections
- More than 25 toppings
- Signature jams inspired by Mama Anita’s original recipes
Every scoop can be customized to create a dessert experience that is uniquely yours.
Visit Our Penn Plaza Location
Operating Hours
Friday – Sunday: 8am – 12amMonday – Thursday: 8am – 11pm
Lovingly Prepared Using Mama Anita's Recipes
For more than two decades, Anita has perfected recipes built around premium ingredients, creativity, and family tradition. Every flavor served at our Penn Plaza location is inspired by those original recipes and prepared with the same attention to detail that has made Anita Gelato an international favorite.
Our handcrafted approach, extensive flavor selection, and commitment to quality have helped establish us as a destination for guests searching for artisan gelato NYC visitors and locals can enjoy throughout the year.
Whether you prefer rich chocolate creations, roasted pistachio favorites, refreshing fruit sorbets, or indulgent dessert-inspired flavors, there is always something waiting to be discovered.
The Perfect Stop Before or After the Game
Few locations are better positioned for dessert lovers than our Midtown Manhattan shop. Located near Madison Square Garden, Penn Station, and some of New York City’s busiest attractions, Anita Gelato is the ideal place to stop before an event, after a show, or while exploring the neighborhood.
Guests looking for gelato near Madison Square Garden can enjoy a quick scoop, relax with a coffee, or take their favorite flavors to go.
Explore Anita Gelato New York
If you’re searching for a gelato shop in Midtown New York that combines premium ingredients, handcrafted recipes, and world-famous flavors, Anita Gelato Penn Plaza is ready to welcome you.
Visit us today and discover why so many guests consider Anita one of the best destinations for boutique gelato Manhattan has to offer.
NEW?
Some desserts are just there for the moment. You enjoy them, and that’s that. Others linger a bit, and you find yourself thinking about them later. That’s where Anita Gelato fits in. It started small, in a family kitchen. Mama Anita and her son Nir making frozen treats, figuring things out as they went. People noticed. And then they kept coming back for more. More than 20 years later, that same spirit still shows up in every colorful tray, generous topping, and the first bite that makes you pause for a second.
Every scoop starts ahead of the game at Anita. The gelato is crafted by hand, churned fresh in-store, and offered in a dazzling rotation of over 150 flavors. Then come the toppings, turning each perfect scoop into a celebration. Suddenly, your gelato is not just creamy or cold, but it also crackles, sparkles, and shows off a personality all of its own. 🍦
You know that moment when your gelato arrives and you pause for a second before eating it? Not on purpose, just… it looks too good to eat! The scoop holds its shape well and the ridges are soft but defined, and the color feels almost too clean to be real. Someone at the table says “wait, don’t touch it yet,” and suddenly phones are out. That’s really all this is. Catching that moment before it melts into something else.
